Living Between Two Cultures: A Digital Literature Discussion of Return to Sender by Julia Alvarez, Part 2
By Andrea García, Hofstra University, Hempstead, NY, and Carmen Martínez-Roldán, Universtiy of Texas, Austin, TX
Literature educates not only the head, but the heart as well. It promotes empathy and invites readers to adopt new perspectives. It offers opportunities for children to learn to recognize our similarities, value our differences, and respect our common humanity. In an important sense, then children need literature that serves as a window onto lives and experiences different from their own, and literature that serves as a mirror reflecting themselves and their cultural values, attitudes, and behaviors. Bishop, cited in Wolf, 2003
Literature can become a conduit-a door-to engage children in social practices that function for social justice. Botelho & Rudman, 2009, p. 1
When inviting teachers to share their initial responses to Return to Sender, focusing on the ideas or themes that resonated personally to them as readers, Cynthia created a Graffiti Board response that zeroed in on the larger sociopolitical issues that frame the story. Return to Sender has the potential not only to serve as window and mirror for many readers but also to invite children and teachers to engage in social practices that function for social justice. Throughout the novel, Alvarez presents a multiplicity of voices on critical issues with consequences for social justice, such as the issue of immigration and undocumented immigrants. This week we would like to focus on one specific event in the story: the town meeting held in the school lunchroom. Julia Alvarez captured both the anti-immigrant discourse and a critical alternative discourse. The first discourse is represented in that scene by Mr. Rossetti who proposes, “So, I want to put a motion forward that says that anyone who’s not here legally needs to be rounded up” (p. 189), an ideology enacted in real life by Immigration and Customs Enforcement through “Operation Return to Sender” in 2006.
(Continued)




